前纽约市长Rudy Giuliani的说法最近引起了不少争论，但我个人很认同他的看法。Giuliani之前就说过这次大选的本质是「实用主义」和「意识形态」之争，我非常认同。
, "When you say black lives matter, that's inherently racist. Black lives matter. White lives matter. Asian lives matter. Hispanic lives matter. That's anti-American, and it's racist." Giuliani also had some thoughts about being black, "If I were a black father and I was concerned about the safety of my child, really concerned about it and not in a politically activist sense, I would say be very respectful to the police, most of them are good, some can be very bad and just be very careful. I'd also say be very careful of those kids in the neighborhood, don't get involved with them because son, there's a 99 percent chance they're going to kill you not the police."
著名脱口秀主持人Seth Meyers对此的反应是这样的：
Seth Meyers put it well on his show last night: "First of all, don't ever start a sentence with the phrase 'If I were a black father.' If you are a black father, you don't need to say it. And if you're not, you should probably just shut the fuck up."
这个就明显是意识形态和政治正确的评价了，就像Nigger只能黑人自称或者称呼同样是黑人的人。因为对方不是黑人所以没资格评价黑人，那还谈什么种族和解呢。所以我才觉得和马丁路德金的民权运动不同，BLM运动倒像是个政治阴谋，它的目的不是和平表达黑人诉求，促进种族和解，而是希望割裂黑人社区和主流社会的立场。到目前为止，没有任何一个有影响力的黑人如同金博士一样，公开声称反暴力，号召和平表达诉求。BLM运动如果成功了黑人就成为高人一等的群体，即使他们学术和社会贡献乏善可陈；失败了那就让黑人进一步被边缘化被歧视。我觉得头脑清楚的黑人精英应该警惕这个运动，通过民运提高自己的地位就是有限度的，如果黑人群体本身的经济能力、对社会的贡献不济，那他们必然不会像犹太人那样翻身成上层阶层。如果说以前对于黑人的歧视是来源于他们的肤色和种族，现在对于他们的成见更多的来自他们的社区暴力文化、高犯罪率、高单亲家庭比例、低大学文凭持有率等等。如果想真正赢得尊重，这些是黑人群体自身必须改进的。
